Apple battles US over scope of ebooks injunction

Advertisement
By Reuters | Updated: 26 August 2013 10:18 IST
Apple battles US over scope of ebooks injunction
The United States offered to ease the terms of a proposed civil injunction against Apple Inc for conspiring to raise ebook prices, but the company said the revised proposal is still designed to "inflict punishment" and must be rejected.

(Also see: US proposes remedy for Apple ebook price-fixing)

At issue is how to ensure that Apple does not violate antitrust law, following a July 10 ruling by U.S. District Judge Denise Cote in Manhattan that it had conspired with five major publishers to undermine pricing by rivals including Amazon.com Inc, which dominates the market for electronic books.

(Also see: Apple conspired to raise prices of ebooks, rules judge)

Apple says the government is overreaching by insisting that it hire an external monitor, let ebook retailers add hyperlinks to their own websites in their ebook apps without charge, and face limits on how it negotiates for other content including movies, music and TV shows.

Cote must approved any injunction.

In a court filing, the U.S. Department of Justice, joined by 33 U.S. states and territories, suggested halving the length of its previously proposed injunction to five years from 10, with leave to seek as many as five one-year extensions if needed.

Advertisement

At Cote's suggestion, they also recommended that Apple hold staggered negotiations with the publishers starting in two years, hopefully minimizing the chance of future collusion, and removed previously proposed language that they said Apple had claimed would hurt its ability to run its popular App Store.

But in rejecting other changes that the company wanted, and while expressing a desire not to "unnecessarily harm Apple," the governments said the Cupertino, California-based company's continuing refusal to admit it did anything wrong warranted tough medicine.

Advertisement

"Quite simply, Apple wants to continue business as usual, regardless of the antitrust laws," the filing said. "This court should have no confidence that Apple on its own effectively can ensure that its illegal conduct will not be repeated. There must be significant oversight by someone not entrenched in Apple's culture of insensitivity to basic tenets of antitrust law."

Letter and spirit of law
In a separate court filing, Apple said the proposal for an external monitor "exceeds the bounds of even criminal price-fixing cases," and reflects an effort "to use this civil injunction to inflict punishment, which is impermissible."

Advertisement

The company said its own proposed remedies are stringent enough, and enable it to remain "one of the world's most innovative companies, while acting consistently with both the letter and spirit of the antitrust laws."

Apple has said it is appealing from Cote's July 10 ruling.

The five publishers, all of which have settled with regulators, include Lagardere SCA's Hachette Book Group Inc, News Corp's HarperCollins Publishers LLC, Penguin Random House LLC, CBS Corp's Simon & Schuster Inc, and Verlagsgruppe Georg von Holtzbrinck GmbH's Macmillan.

Cote has scheduled a May 2014 trial to determine damages, which could total hundreds of millions of dollars.

She had ordered both sides to hold talks to resolve their differences over an injunction, but the talks failed. The governments said some of Apple's proposals were even less restrictive than what the publishers had accepted.

Gina Talamona, a Justice Department spokeswoman, was not immediately available for comment. Tom Neumayr, an Apple spokesman, was not immediately available for comment.

The case is U.S. v. Apple Inc et al, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No. 12-02826.

© Thomson Reuters 2013

 

For the latest tech news and reviews, follow Gadgets 360 on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News. For the latest videos on gadgets and tech, subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you want to know everything about top influencers, follow our in-house Who'sThat360 on Instagram and YouTube.

Further reading: Apple, Internet, ebooks
Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Nothing Phone 3 to Be Equipped With the Snapdragon 8s Gen 4 SoC
  2. OnePlus Nord 5 and Nord CE 5 Colour Options, Key Features Leaked
  3. Samsung Galaxy M36 5G to Launch in India Soon; Design, Price Range Teased
  4. Trump Mobile T1 Phone With 5,000mAh Battery Announced; See Price, Features
  5. Amazfit Active 2 Square Debuts With 1.75-Inch AMOLED Display
  6. Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra Price in India Discounted for a Limited Time
  7. Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 Series Design Revealed in New Leaked Renders
  8. Meta Might Be Trying to Fix the Privacy Problem of Its AI App
  1. Nintendo Direct Livestream Featuring Donkey Kong Bananza Announced for June 18
  2. Amazfit Active 2 Square Debuts With 1.75-Inch AMOLED Display and Up to 10 Days Battery Life
  3. Samsung’s Exynos 2500 SoC Confirmed to Feature Satellite Connectivity Ahead of Galaxy Z Flip 7 Launch
  4. Nothing Phone 3 Confirmed to Come With Snapdragon 8s Gen 4 SoC Ahead of July 1 Launch
  5. Samsung Galaxy M36 5G India Launch Teased; Rear Design and Price Range Revealed
  6. Reddit Unveils Reddit Community Intelligence, Its Suite of AI-Powered Ad Tools for Enterprises
  7. Sony Bravia 8 II QD-OLED TV Series With Acoustic Surface+ Audio, Studio Calibrated Mode Launched in India
  8. Asus Unveils Refreshed Vivobook S16, S16 OLED Laptops in India Alongside Vivobook S14: Price, Features
  9. Apple Watch Ultra 3 Said to Launch This Year; Product Roadmap for Next Three Years Leaked
  10. Google Unveils India-Focused Safety Charter, Shares How It Is Using AI to Combat Online Frauds and Scams
Gadgets 360 is available in
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2025. All rights reserved.