YouTube's New Attempt to Limit Propaganda Draws Fire From PBS

Advertisement
By Hamza Shaban, The Washington Post | Updated: 5 February 2018 14:50 IST

YouTube users in the United States will soon see a new label pinned to videos published by news outlets that receive government funding.

The popular video service said Friday that the new notices are intended to help audiences better understand their sources of news, and they come amid a US government crackdown on a Russian-funded news organisation that the US intelligence community has characterised as a propaganda outlet for the Kremlin.

Advertisement

YouTube's decision to flag state-backed media is the latest example of Silicon Valley's struggle to contend with the spread of disinformation across social media, a tactic exploited by foreign operatives during and after the 2016 presidential election. It also highlights the increasing challenges giant communications platforms face as they assume regulatory responsibilities in facilitating and policing the global public square.

"News is an important and growing vertical for us, and we want to be sure to get it right, helping to grow news and support news publishers on YouTube in a responsible way," Geoff Samek, senior product manager for YouTube News, said in a blog post. "This work follows a series of changes we made throughout 2017 to better surface authoritative news content."

Advertisement

But PBS, a US public broadcaster, says YouTube's decision is misguided. "Labelling PBS a 'publicly funded broadcaster' is both vague and misleading," a spokesman told The Washington Post is a statement. "PBS and its member stations receive a small percentage of funding from the federal government; the majority of funding comes from private donations. More importantly, PBS is an independent, private, not-for-profit corporation, not a state broadcaster. YouTube's proposed labelling could wrongly imply that the government has influence over PBS content, which is prohibited by statute. If YouTube's intent is to create clarity and better understanding, this is a step in the wrong direction."

PBS added that it continues to discuss the issue with YouTube.

Advertisement

When asked to address the criticism levelled by PBS and to offer further details, Google, YouTube's parent company, referred The Post back to Samek's blog post.

"We're rolling out this feature to viewers in the US for now, and we don't expect it to be perfect," YouTube's Samek wrote. "We plan to improve and expand the feature over time."

Advertisement

YouTube did not disclose a list of posters affected by the new labels. But in the blog post, the company included an example of a flagged video from Radio Free Asia, a nonprofit news organisation funded by the Broadcasting Board of Governors, a US government agency, whose stated mission is "to inform, engage, and connect people around the world in support of freedom and democracy." The sample notice on the YouTube video stated "RFA is funded in whole or in part by the American government."

The notices will appear below the video but above the video's title, YouTube said; the label also will include a link to the publisher's Wikipedia page. On a Web page offering additional details about the labels, YouTube said that the notice is "not a comment by YouTube on the publisher's or video's editorial direction or a government's editorial influence." The state-funded labels will not be displayed in YouTube search results, and they will not affect any video features or change the criteria for enabling advertisements on videos, YouTube said.

YouTube's move arrives as Facebook, Twitter and Google were attacked by lawmakers for not doing enough to prevent foreign meddling on their networks during the election. In contentious congressional hearings last year, members of Congress also pressed Google on its relationship with the Russian-backed news outlet RT, formerly known as Russia Today, which the US intelligence community had concluded is a propaganda platform for Moscow. RT did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

In November, Eric Schmidt, the former executive chairman of Google's parent, Alphabet, said that the company would de-rank RT and another Russian government-affiliated news outlet, Sputnik, in its search results in an effort to curb misleading and exploitative content. Schmidt added that the company does not want to ban the outlets, and Google later clarified that the company does not re-rank individual websites.

Google is not the only tech giant to have taken action against Russian-affiliated media. In October, Twitter banned RT and Sputnik from advertising on its platform, citing the US intelligence assessment.

The thorny issue over state-backed media playing out on tech platforms is part of a broader conflict between the US and Russian governments. Russian President Vladimir Putin recently signed into law new measures that will allow authorities to force any foreign media organisation to register as a "foreign agent." The policy, enacted in retaliation after RT was forced to register under a similar statute in the United States, could entangle US news bureaus abroad and may lead Moscow to enact further censorship rules.

© The Washington Post 2018

 

Get your daily dose of tech news, reviews, and insights, in under 80 characters on Gadgets 360 Turbo. Connect with fellow tech lovers on our Forum. Follow us on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News for instant updates. Catch all the action on our YouTube channel.

Further reading: Internet, Google, YouTube, PBS, US
Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Xiaomi Smart Band 11 Launched With 1.72-Inch AMOLED Display
  1. OpenAI Expands ChatGPT for Academic Researchers Programme to India With Free Plus Access
  2. Xiaomi 18 Pro Max, Xiaomi 18 Pro Launched Globally With Privacy Display, Dual 200-Megapixel Cameras: Price, Features
  3. OpenAI Brings Computer-Use AI Agents to Healthcare for Medical Records and Insurance Workflows
  4. Pump.fun Adds Prediction Markets as It Looks Beyond Memecoin Trading
  5. Sony Rolls Out New PS5 System Software Update With 'Security Fixes' Ahead of GTA 6 Launch
  6. Gemini Users Can Now Save Their Chat History Without Opting in to AI Model Training
  7. Ex-Robinhood Engineer Admits Guilt in $125,000 Hyperliquid Fraud Case
  8. Oppo Find X11 Pro Max Tipped to Get Flat Screen, Quad-Curved Glass
  9. EvoFox Play V Wireless Gamepad Launched in India With Magnetic Hall 3D Joysticks for Sony’s PS5, PC and Smartphones
  10. WhatsApp Rolling Out Cloud Storage for Chat Backups on Android: Report
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2026. All rights reserved.