Tesla Shares Only 1 Percent Blame for Fatal Crash That Killed Two Teens, Rules Jury

Tuesday's verdict placed 90 percent of the blame on the driver, Barrett Riley, and 9 percent on his father, James Riley.

Advertisement
By Associated Press | Updated: 20 July 2022 23:22 IST
Highlights
  • NTSB said the car's speed was likely the cause of the crash
  • Teen's father blamed Tesla removed a speed limiter without his permission
  • Tesla argued the teen's parents were negligent for letting him drive

Tesla denied negligence in disabling the speed limiter

A jury in Florida has found Tesla just one percent negligent in a fiery crash that killed two teens, for disabling a speed limiter on the electric car.

Tuesday's verdict placed 90 percent of the blame on the driver, Barrett Riley, and 9 percent on his father, James Riley, who brought the lawsuit against Tesla.

Advertisement

It's the first known case involving a Tesla crash that has gone to trial, said Michael Brooks, acting exective director at the Center for Auto Safety.

Barrett and his friend Edgar Monserrat Martinez were about to graduate from their private school in South Florida when they died in the May 2018 crash near Fort Lauderdale Beach. A backseat passenger was ejected and survived.

Advertisement

The National Transportation Safety Board determined he was driving at 116 miles per hour (186km per hour) in a 30 miles per hour (48km per hour) zone, and the most likely cause of the crash “was the driver's loss of control as a result of excessive speed.”

James claimed the crash was “entirely survivable” and that it was the ensuing fire that killed the teenagers, but the judge dismissed his lawsuit's claim that Tesla designed defective lithium ion batteries that “burst into an uncontrollable and fatal fire” upon impact.

Advertisement

James also said Tesla removed a speed limiter without his permission. He had ordered the instrument installed to prevent his son from driving at more than 85 miles per hour (136km per hour).

An investigation found that about a month before the crash, the teen asked workers at Tesla's Dania Beach dealership to return the car to normal operating mode while it was being serviced.

Advertisement

Tesla denied negligence in disabling the speed limiter. The company argued that the teen's parents were negligent in allowing him to drive the vehicle “when they were aware of his history of speeding and reckless driving,” according to the judge's instructions to the jury.

Brooks, at the Center for Auto Safety, said other lawsuits are pending against Tesla involving the vehicle's autopilot and full self-driving systems.

 


What is the best value flagship smartphone? We discuss this on Orbital, the Gadgets 360 podcast. Orbital is available on Spotify, Gaana, JioSaavn, Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music and wherever you get your podcasts.
Affiliate links may be automatically generated - see our ethics statement for details.
 

Get your daily dose of tech news, reviews, and insights, in under 80 characters on Gadgets 360 Turbo. Connect with fellow tech lovers on our Forum. Follow us on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News for instant updates. Catch all the action on our YouTube channel.

Further reading: Tesla, autopilot, car crash
Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Xiaomi 18 Pro vs iPhone 18 Pro vs Pixel 11 Pro: What's the Difference
  2. Xiaomi 18 Pro Max vs iPhone 18 Pro Max vs Oppo Find X10 Pro Max
  1. Logitech MX Master 4 Creator Edition With Customisable Controls, Haptic Feedback Launched in India: Price, Features
  2. SEC Takes Action Against Eight Entities in $37 Million Crypto Fraud Case
  3. Galaxy Z Fold 9, Z Fold 9 Ultra Hit IMEI Database as Samsung Preps Next Foldables
  4. Indian Crypto Exchanges Report INR Withdrawal Disruptions Across Platforms
  5. Samsung’s Googlebooks Codenamed ‘Origin’ Show Up in Leaked One UI 9.5 Beta Code
  6. Nothing’s First Screenless AI Device Launches December 8: Design Teased
  7. Vivo V80 FE Could Launch in India in Exclusive Red Colour Option, Tipster Claims
  8. Apple is Reportedly Developing AI Agent for App Control, Web Browsing and Coding
  9. Google Black Friday 2026 Sale Live: Save Up to $600 on Pixel 11, Pixel Watch 5
  10. Dell XPS 16 Creator Edition Laptop With Nvidia RTX Spark N1X Processor Launched in India: Price, Specifications
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2026. All rights reserved.