Facebook Asked to Change Platform Rules for Journalists and Researchers

Advertisement
By Ellen Nakashima, The Washington Post | Updated: 8 August 2018 13:36 IST
Facebook Asked to Change Platform Rules for Journalists and Researchers

A group of First Amendment advocates have urged Facebook Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg to change the social media giant's platform rules to enable public service journalism and research on its platform.

The issue is especially pressing, says Columbia University's Knight First Amendment Institute, as reporters and researchers investigate Russian interference in the midterm elections through platforms such as Facebook's.

In a letter Monday to Zuckerberg, the institute noted that Facebook's terms of service bar the automated collection of public information, a practice that researchers call "scraping," and the creation of temporary research accounts.

Automated collection allows journalists and researchers to generate statistical insights into patterns and information flows on Facebook's platform, said Ramya Krishnan, legal fellow at the Knight institute. Sometimes journalists and researchers have attempted to set up temporary research accounts, using a variety of names and biographical attributes, to enable them to assess how the platform responds to different profiles, she said.

Advertisement

But such practices are barred by Facebook's terms of service, which require that a user "provide accurate information about yourself" and create only one account.

Being able to conduct such research is important because "Facebook's algorithms are opaque and they have enormous influence on our public discourse," Krishnan said. "The only way to test how they work is by using tools like temporary research accounts to test algorithms on their platform."

Advertisement

Journalists who use such techniques may have their accounts suspended and could even risk federal prosecution, said Jameel Jaffer, the Knight institute's executive director. Both Facebook and the Justice Department have at times interpreted the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act to prohibit violations of a website's terms of service, he said.

"We are unaware of any case in which Facebook has brought legal action against a journalist or researcher" for violating its terms of service, the letter said. However, in multiple cases, it said, the company has instructed journalists or researchers to stop investigative projects, claiming that they violate Facebook's user rules.

Advertisement

"The mere possibility of legal action has a significant chilling effect," said the letter, which was written on behalf of a group of journalists and researchers who have worked for the New York Times, PBS NewsHour, Gizmodo Media Group and Princeton University, and the University of Michigan's School of Information.

The Knight institute has proposed a "safe harbor" to allow reporters and researchers to undertake investigations in the public interest that are currently barred by the company's rules.

The revised rules the institute proposes would state that it is not a violation of the firm's terms of service to collect public information "through automated means" or "by creating or using temporary research accounts" as part of a newsgathering or research project, as long as a number of conditions are met. For instance, the project should be about a matter of public concern, steps should be taken to prevent data theft, the data should not be sold or transferred to any ad network or data broker, and no data should be disclosed that identifies a Facebook user without that user's consent.

A Facebook spokesman said the company was reviewing the recommendation. In the meantime, Facebook's head of global news partnerships, Campbell Brown, said in a statement:

"We appreciate the Knight Institute's recommendations. Journalists and researchers play a critical role in helping people better understand companies and their products - as well as holding us accountable when we get things wrong. We do have strict limits in place on how third parties can use people's information, and we recognize that these sometimes get in the way of this work. We offer tools for journalists that protect people's privacy, including CrowdTangle, which helps measure the performance of content on social media, and a new API [software program] we're launching to specifically analyze political advertising on Facebook."

Cameron Hickey, a researcher who worked for Miles O'Brien, a science correspondent for the PBS NewsHour, said that after the 2016 election, he decided to investigate the spread of misinformation on social media. He created software to more easily capture data on hundreds of Facebook pages by identifying who clicked on the "like" button on those pages.

"Once I identified this technique, I became aware that scraping content from Facebook would be a violation of their terms of service," Hickey said. He consulted with NewsHour leadership, who concluded that the legal risks were too great, so he resorted to manual techniques, which were much slower and yielded less data, he said.

Aviv Ovadya, a misinformation researcher who worked for the Center for Social Media Responsibility at the University of Michigan, said the proposed change in the terms of service could actually be beneficial to Facebook by "helping strengthen their platform and helping them identify unintended consequences" they might otherwise miss.

Hickey and Ovadya are among the journalists and researchers whose work prompted the letter.

© The Washington Post 2018

 

For the latest tech news and reviews, follow Gadgets 360 on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News. For the latest videos on gadgets and tech, subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you want to know everything about top influencers, follow our in-house Who'sThat360 on Instagram and YouTube.

Further reading: Facebook, Mark Zuckerberg
Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Vi Non-Stop Hero Prepaid Plans Now Available in These Circles
  2. Redmi Note 14 SE 5G Launched in India With 50-Megapixel Rear Camera
  3. OnePlus Buds 4 Review: The New Standard for Value ANC Earbuds
  4. Vivo V60 to Launch in India Soon; Reportedly Spotted on TRDA Site
  5. iPhone 17 Pro Series Tipped to Come With These Three Camera Upgrades
  6. Vivo Y400 Key Specifications Confirmed; to Launch on This Date
  1. Doomed Exoplanet TOI-2109b Spirals Toward Its Star with Three Possible Fates
  2. Hubble Captures First Images of Ancient Interstellar Visitor Comet 3I/ATLAS
  3. Meet Walker S2: The Self-Sufficient Humanoid Robot with Swappable Battery Tech
  4. Saare Jahan Se Acha OTT Release Date: When and Where to Watch Pratik Gandhi Starrer Movie
  5. The Plot Now Streaming on Lionsgate Play: What You Need to Know About Korean Crime Thriller Movie
  6. Hari Hara Veera Mallu OTT Release Reportedly Revealed: Everything You Need to Know
  7. X&Y Now Streaming on SunNXT: What You Need to Know About This Comedy Kannada Drama Movie
  8. Parijatha Parvam Streaming Now on LionsgatePlay: A Twisted Telugu Crime Comedy Full of Chaos and Laughter
  9. Mortal Kombat: Legacy Kollection's Leaked Release Date Points to September Launch
  10. Primebook 2 Neo With MediaTek Helio G99 SoC to Launch in India on July 31; Price, Specifications Teased
Gadgets 360 is available in
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2025. All rights reserved.