Apple, Google Spark New Privacy Battle With Mobile Encryption Drive

Advertisement
By Agence France-Presse | Updated: 1 October 2014 09:15 IST
Apple, Google Spark New Privacy Battle With Mobile Encryption Drive
A new battle is brewing over privacy for mobile devices, after moves by Google and Apple to toughen the encryption of their mobile devices sparked complaints from law enforcement.

The issue is part of a long-running debate over whether tech gadgets should have privacy-protecting encryption which makes it difficult for law enforcement to access in time-sensitive investigations.

FBI director James Comey reignited the issue last week, criticizing Apple and Google for new measures that keep smartphones locked down without even the company holding the keys to unlock the data.

(Also see: Apple Ensures Even It Can't Access User Data on iOS 8 Devices)

"What concerns me about this is companies marketing something expressly to allow people to place themselves beyond the law," the FBI chief said, warning that law enforcement may be denied timely access, even with a warrant, in cases ranging from child kidnapping to terrorism.

Advertisement

Former FBI criminal division chief Ronald Hosko made a similar point in an opinion piece in the Washington Post, citing a case in which the agency used smartphone data to solve a brutal kidnapping just in time to save the life of the victim.

"Most investigations don't rely solely on information from one source, even a smartphone," he said. "But without each and every important piece of the investigative puzzle, criminals and those who plan acts destructive to our national security may walk free."

Advertisement

Crypto Wars 2.0
Observers who follow privacy and encryption say they have seen this debate before.

In the mid-1990s, as the Internet was gaining traction, the government pressed for access to digital "keys" to any encryption software or hardware, before abandoning what ended up being a futile effort.

Advertisement

"This is Crypto Wars 2.0," says Joseph Hall of the Center for Democracy and Technology, a digital rights group active in both campaigns.

Today, "the main difference is that phones are increasingly deeply personal, containing much more daily life and interaction than a desktop from the 1990s" Hall said.

Hall argued that giving law enforcement access requires companies to "engineer vulnerabilities" which could be exploited by hackers or others.

"There's no way to tell the difference between a good guy and bad guy when they walk through the back door," he said.

Cindy Cohn of the Electronic Frontier Foundation says the FBI has been making these arguments since 1995, with the same flawed logic.

"We've seen this movie before," Cohn said.

"Regulating and controlling consumer use of encryption was a monstrous proposal officially declared in 2001," she said in a blog post. "But like a zombie, it's now rising from the grave, bringing the same disastrous flaws with it."

In 2013, before the revelations of massive surveillance from leaked National Security Agency documents, the FBI called for broader authority to capture mobile communications which fall outside traditional surveillance, such as Skype and Google Hangouts.

But civil liberties activities say leaked NSA documents suggest that contrary to FBI claims made last year, the government has many tools at its disposal.

"There are an increasing number of places where we leave our digital trails," Hall said, including in the Internet cloud, where it can be accessed with a court order.

No back doors
Jennifer Granick, director of civil liberties at the Stanford University Center for Internet and Society, said the FBI argument overlooks the fact US tech firms must compete in the global marketplace.

"Global customers do not want backdoored products any more than Americans do, and with very good reason," Granick writes on the "Just Security" blog.

"Authoritarian countries like Russia, China, the United Arab Emirates, Sudan, and Saudi Arabia want to censor, spy on, and control their citizens' communications. These nations are just as able to make demands that Apple and Google decrypt devices as the FBI is, and to back up those demands with effective threats."

On balance, she said, "the public is more secure, not less secure, with the wide use of strong cryptography including cryptography without back doors."

Mike Janke, chief executive of the firm Silent Circle which makes the fully encrypted Blackphone, said the FBI is making a "false cry" against Google and Apple because the law enforcement agency can easily gain access to a phone through a carrier tap, or location tracking, for example.

Greater privacy, Janke said, comes from the harder encryption on Blackphone, but law enforcement can still track a user's location as long as the battery is inside.

While a small number of people may use encryption for nefarious purposes, Janke said, "do you sacrifice the privacy and trade secrets of everyone else because of that?"

 

For the latest tech news and reviews, follow Gadgets 360 on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News. For the latest videos on gadgets and tech, subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you want to know everything about top influencers, follow our in-house Who'sThat360 on Instagram and YouTube.

Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Tecno Pova 7 5G, Pova 7 Pro 5G Launched in India: Price, Availability
  2. Here's How Much the Vivo X Fold 5 and Vivo X200 FE Might Cost in India
  3. OTT Releases This Week: Kaalidhar Laapata, Thug Life, The Good Wife, and More
  4. NxtQuantum Arrives as Made in India Mobile OS, to Debut on Its AI+ Phones
  5. Apple Plans to Launch M5-Powered MacBook Pro This Year: Report
  6. The Good Wife OTT Release Date: When and Where to Watch it Online?
  7. Tecno Spark 40 Pro+, Spark 40 Pro and Spark 40 Launched: All Details
  1. EA Is Shutting Down BioWare's Anthem Next Year
  2. NxtQuantum Announced as India’s Home-Grown Mobile Operating System, to Debut on AI+ Pulse and Nova 5G
  3. Tecno Pova 7 5G, Pova 7 Pro 5G Launched in India With MediaTek Dimensity 7300 Ultimate SoC
  4. Google Pixel 6a Owners Eligible for $100 Cash or $150 Store Credit Under Battery Performance Programme
  5. Meta AI Chatbots Will Soon Send Users Proactive Follow-Up Messages to Boost Engagement: Report
  6. Android 16’s Live Updates to Show Active Navigation, Ongoing Phone Calls, and More on Lock Screen
  7. Helldivers 2 is Coming to Xbox Series S/X Next Month, Pre-Orders Now Live
  8. Vivo X Fold 5, Vivo X200 FE Price in India Leaked Ahead of Debut on July 14
  9. Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 7 Design Spotted in Leaked Hands-On Images Ahead of July 9 Launch
  10. iPhone 17 Pro Max Could Get a Battery Upgrade Over Its Predecessor; May ‘Reach’ 5,000mAh Capacity
Gadgets 360 is available in
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2025. All rights reserved.