Apple, Samsung legal battle hits the 'hot tub'

Advertisement
By Reuters | Updated: 8 August 2012 10:57 IST

Apple Inc and Samsung Electronics Co Ltd are embroiled in a high-stakes patent battle in several countries around the world, but only in Australia are they also engaged in "hot tubbing."

Rather than a gaggle of lawyers hammering out their differences in the jacuzzi, the term refers to expert witnesses giving evidence in court together - rather than one by one - in the witness box.

Officially known by the more staid legal term of "concurrent evidence", the practice has become increasingly common in Australia in complex, technical trials such as the Apple-Samsung patent dispute.

Proponents argue that it saves time and resources and, importantly, restrains experts hired by litigants from overstating their case as they can immediately be questioned not only by the judge and lawyers, but by their peers.

"I think in a case like this it's quite a good approach," said Mark Summerfield, a patent lawyer and senior associate at Melbourne-based law firm Watermark.

Australia is one several countries where Apple and Samsung are in battle over patents. Apple has accused Samsung of copying the design and function of some of its tablet and smartphone devices, while Samsung has counter-sued Apple for allegedly breaching patents related to wireless transmission technology. A U.S. Federal Court began its own high profile case last week.

The hot tub approach temporarily switches Australia's adversarial court system into more of an inquisitorial system that is widely followed in Europe and Asia.

"The basic theory is that if an expert is in a position like that ... they will be more upfront about what they really think and they'll be more willing to discuss the nuances of points," said Summerfield. "It also tempers the tendency of barristers to be aggressive in questioning."

Copyright Thomson Reuters 2012

 

Get your daily dose of tech news, reviews, and insights, in under 80 characters on Gadgets 360 Turbo. Connect with fellow tech lovers on our Forum. Follow us on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News for instant updates. Catch all the action on our YouTube channel.

Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Apple's 20th Anniversary iPhone Might Arrive With This New Camera Sensor
  2. GTA 6's New Dynamic Weather System Detailed Ahead of Launch
  3. Airtel Announces Insider Offers Worth Over Rs. 30,000
  4. Xiaomi Wide-Screen Smartphone Details Emerge as Display Enters Testing
  5. Bitcoin Trades Near $65,000 as Options Traders Seek Downside Protection
  6. Vivo V80 FE Confirmed to Launch Soon Globally: See Specifications
  1. Star Wars: Galactic Racer Is Getting a Local Split-Screen Multiplayer Mode in Early 2027
  2. iPhone Duo Gets Facial Unlocking, Close-to-Lock Feature With iOS 27.3 Beta Update
  3. Vivo V80 FE Confirmed to Launch Soon Globally With 50-Megapixel Rear Cameras, 7,000mAh Battery
  4. Samsung Galaxy S28 Series Could Bring Back Variable Aperture Cameras
  5. Leaked Bixby 5.0 APK Reveals New Interface and Memory Feature For AI Assistant Ahead of One UI 9.5 Release
  6. Samsung Galaxy Studio Design, Colour Options Revealed in New Leak 
  7. iQOO Z12 Lite Chipset, Design and Other Details Appear in Google Play Console Listing
  8. Rockstar Games Details Grand Theft Auto 6's New Dynamic Weather System Ahead of Launch
  9. Xiaomi May Launch a Wide-Screen Phone With 6.4-Inch Display and Ultra-Thin Bezels
  10. Bitcoin Trades Near $65,000 as Options Traders Seek Downside Protection
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2026. All rights reserved.