Google CEO Sundar Pichai Spars With US Lawmakers on Bias, Privacy

Advertisement
By Agence France-Presse | Updated: 12 December 2018 12:01 IST
Highlights
  • "We build our products in a neutral way," said Sundar Pichai
  • "We approach our work without any political bias"
  • "Right now we have no plans to launch in China," he said

Photo Credit: Alex Wong/ Getty Images/ AFP

Google chief executive Sundar Pichai parried US lawmakers Tuesday over complaints of political bias and intrusive data collection as the Internet giant came under heavy criticism from conservatives.

"We build our products in a neutral way," Pichai said in one exchange with a lawmaker, and added later: "We approach our work without any political bias."

Advertisement

Pichai was called to the House Judiciary Committee following a series of attacks by President Donald Trump and his supporters claiming that Google and other Internet platforms were suppressing conservative voices, despite persistent denials from the companies.

The hearing on Google's "data collection, use and filtering practices" offered an opportunity for lawmakers to confront the CEO over claims that the Internet giant skews its search results for political reasons.

Advertisement

Google angered lawmakers earlier this year by refusing to send a top executive to a similar hearing with Facebook and Twitter.

The latest hearing comes with Silicon Valley under fire over privacy practices and manipulation, including by foreign governments, and possible monopoly practices.

Advertisement

Committee chairman Bob Goodlatte said it would be "sinister" for Google to manipulate its search engine because of its vast ability to control information people see online.

"The American people deserve to know what kinds of information they are not getting when they are doing a search on the Internet," Goodlatte said.

Advertisement

Pichai, dressed in a dark suit, calmly responded to questions, repeating on several occasions that the company seeks to serve a range of viewpoints without bias.

He took on Republican Representative Lamar Smith of Texas, who said it was "irrefutable" that Google's search results were biased.

Pichai replied that "providing users with high-quality and trusted information is sacrosanct to us... we find we have a wide variety of sources including from the left and the right."

He said search algorithms reflect factors such as "relevance, freshness (and) popularity," and added that "we try to reflect what is newsworthy, what is currently being discussed."

'Fake news'
Trump earlier this year took aim at Google, tweeting that search results were "rigged" against him, promoting negative stories from media outlets he considers "fake news."

Some lawmakers raised the prospect of new regulations or modifying the exemption from liability that Internet firms enjoy for content from third parties.

Louie Gohmert, a Texas Republican, argued that Google was "surrounded by liberality" and did not recognize its own bias.

But Democrat Jerry Nadler called the bias issue a "fantasy" drummed up by conservatives and said "no evidence supports this right-wing conspiracy theory."

California Democrat Ted Lieu called the hearing "a waste of time" and ridiculed the comments about constitutional rights under the First Amendment.

"The First Amendment limits what the government can do on regulating speech, it does not limit Google," Lieu said.

What does Google know?
Pichai also faced comments and questions about Google's data collection and privacy practices, and its discussions on creating a search engine that could be used in China.

Goodlatte said the tech giant was "able to collect an amount of information about its users that would even make the NSA (National Security Agency) blush," arguing that the company needed to be more transparent about what it does with location and other data on Android-powered devices.

Pichai said the data collected would depend on the applications installed and privacy options chosen.

"We remind users to do a privacy checkup and we make it very obvious... they can clearly see what information we have," he said.

He also sought to deflect criticism over "Project Dragonfly," a hotly contested project that could offer a search engine that would satisfy Chinese censors.

"Right now we have no plans to launch in China," he said.

 

Get your daily dose of tech news, reviews, and insights, in under 80 characters on Gadgets 360 Turbo. Connect with fellow tech lovers on our Forum. Follow us on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News for instant updates. Catch all the action on our YouTube channel.

Further reading: Google, Sundar Pichai
Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Redmi R80 5G, Redmi R80m 5G Listed Online With Dimensity 6300 SoC
  2. Samsung Galaxy S27 Pro Could Launch in India With This 2nm Exynos Chipset
  3. Samsung Is Working on 14-Inch and 16-Inch Wi-Fi Googlebooks
  4. Dell XPS 16 Creator Edition With Nvidia RTX Spark Launched in India
  1. SEC Takes Action Against Eight Entities in $37 Million Crypto Fraud Case
  2. Galaxy Z Fold 9, Z Fold 9 Ultra Hit IMEI Database as Samsung Preps Next Foldables
  3. Indian Crypto Exchanges Report INR Withdrawal Disruptions Across Platforms
  4. Samsung’s Googlebooks Codenamed ‘Origin’ Show Up in Leaked One UI 9.5 Beta Code
  5. Nothing’s First Screenless AI Device Launches December 8: Design Teased
  6. Vivo V80 FE Could Launch in India in Exclusive Red Colour Option, Tipster Claims
  7. Apple is Reportedly Developing AI Agent for App Control, Web Browsing and Coding
  8. Google Black Friday 2026 Sale Live: Save Up to $600 on Pixel 11, Pixel Watch 5
  9. Dell XPS 16 Creator Edition Laptop With Nvidia RTX Spark N1X Processor Launched in India: Price, Specifications
  10. A Cheaper Legion Go 2? Lenovo Legion Go Beam Handheld Leaks in Images
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2026. All rights reserved.