Microsoft's LinkedIn Loses Appeal Over Access to User Profiles

hiQ showed it faced irreparable harm absent an injunction because it might go out of business without access.

Advertisement
By Reuters | Updated: 10 September 2019 12:45 IST
Microsoft's LinkedIn Loses Appeal Over Access to User Profiles

Photo Credit: Washington Post photo by Geoffrey Fowler

A federal appeals court on Monday rejected LinkedIn's effort to stop a San Francisco company from using information that users of the professional networking website have deemed public.

The 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals let stand an August 2017 preliminary injunction that required LinkedIn, a Microsoft unit with more than 645 million members, to give hiQ Labs access to publicly available member profiles.

The 3-0 decision by the San Francisco appeals court sets back Silicon Valley's battle against "data scraping," or extracting information from social media accounts or websites, which critics say can equate to theft or violate users' privacy.

Circuit Judge Marsha Berzon said hiQ, which makes software to help employers determine whether employees will stay or quit, showed it faced irreparable harm absent an injunction because it might go out of business without access.

Advertisement

She also said giving companies such as LinkedIn "free rein" over who can use public user data risked creating "information monopolies" that harm the public interest.

"LinkedIn has no protected property interest in the data contributed by its users, as the users retain ownership over their profiles," Berzon wrote. "And as to the publicly available profiles, the users quite evidently intend them to be accessed by others," including prospective employers.

Advertisement

In a statement, LinkedIn said it was disappointed with the decision and evaluating its options, and will "fight to protect our members and the information they entrust" to it.

Lawyers for hiQ did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The case was returned to US District Judge Edward Chen in San Francisco, who issued the injunction.

Advertisement

Craigslist, the classified ad website, had supported LinkedIn's appeal, warning that the injunction could have a "dangerous impact" by making it easier for "bad actors" to find targets for unwanted email, text or phone-based marketing.

Berzon said, however, hiQ had raised serious questions about LinkedIn's conduct, including whether it could invoke a federal law targeting computer fraud and abuse to block "free riders" from accessing user data.

"Of course, LinkedIn could satisfy its 'free rider' concern by eliminating the public access option, albeit at a cost to the preferences of many users and, possibly, to its own bottom line," she wrote.

Gregory Garre, a former US solicitor general under President George W. Bush representing craigslist, did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Donald Verrilli, a solicitor general under President Barack Obama, represented LinkedIn. Harvard Law School professor Laurence Tribe was one of hiQ's lawyers.

The case is hiQ Labs v LinkedIn Corp, 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 17-16783.

© Thomson Reuters 2019

 

For the latest tech news and reviews, follow Gadgets 360 on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News. For the latest videos on gadgets and tech, subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you want to know everything about top influencers, follow our in-house Who'sThat360 on Instagram and YouTube.

Further reading: LinkedIn, hiQ Labs
Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Vivo Y400 Pro 5G: Everything We Know Ahead of India Launch on June 20
  2. Oppo Reno 14 5G, Reno 14 Pro 5G India Launch Timeline Leaked
  3. BSNL Announces Name of Its 5G Service in India
  4. OnePlus Bullets Wireless Z3 With Up to 36 Hours Battery Launched in India
  5. Oppo Reno 14 5G Series Teased to Launch in India Soon
  6. Poco F7 5G to Be Equipped With a Snapdragon 8s Gen 4 SoC
  7. Apple's Foldable iPhone to Enter Production Later This Year: Ming-Chi Kuo
  8. Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 7, Z Flip 7 Launch Date Leaked Online
  9. Realme 15 Series Said to Launch in July; Lite Variant Leaked Online
  10. Vivo T4 Lite 5G to Launch in India on June 24; Chipset Confirmed
  1. Realme 15 Series Launch Timeline Leaked; Lite Variant Surfaces Online
  2. Oppo Reno 14 5G Series India Launch Confirmed: Expected Price, Specifications
  3. Google Messages Widely Rolling Out Snooze Notifications and Delete for Everyone Features
  4. OnePlus Bullets Wireless Z3 With 12.4mm Drivers, Up to 36 Hours of Battery Life Launched in India
  5. Microsoft Planning Thousands More Job Cuts Aimed at Salespeople
  6. Vivo T4 Lite 5G India Launch Date Announced; to Feature MediaTek Dimensity 6300 SoC
  7. Coinbase Launches Stablecoin Payments Service for E-Commerce
  8. Iran Crypto Exchange Nobitex Hit by Hackers, $90 Million Destroyed
  9. Vodafone Idea Partners With AST SpaceMobile to Bring Direct-to-Device Satellite Connectivity to India
  10. Microsoft Said to Be Prepared to Abandon High-Stakes Talks with OpenAI
Gadgets 360 is available in
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2025. All rights reserved.