Society of Manufacturers of Electric Vehicles on Tuesday said the sudden reduction of subsidy for electric two-wheelers may lead to a major decline in EV adoption, impacting the entire industry for a considerable period of time.
Startup players in the electric mobility space, however, welcomed the government's decision saying it was time for the EV industry to stand on its own.
The Heavy Industries Ministry has notified changes for reducing subsidy provided under FAME-II (Faster Adoption of Manufacturing of Electric Vehicles in India) scheme applicable on electric two-wheelers registered on or after June 1, 2023.
Subsequently, for electric two-wheelers, the demand incentive will be Rs 10,000 per kWh. The cap on incentives for electric two-wheelers will be 15 percent of the ex-factory price of vehicles from 40 percent at present.
Reacting to the changes, Society of Manufacturers of Electric Vehicles (SMEV) Director General Sohinder Gill said, "The sudden reduction of subsidy may lead to a major decline in EV adoption, impacting the entire industry for a considerable period of time." The ground reality is that the Indian market remains price-sensitive, and the total cost of ownership is not firmly established in consumers' minds, he asserted.
Gill further said with the majority of petrol two-wheelers costing less than Rs. 1 lakh, there are fewer chances of consumer spending upwards of Rs. 1.5 lakh just factoring in the total cost of ownership.
"A gradual transition with sustained subsidies would have been ideal to ensure market growth and reach the international benchmark of 20 percent EV adoption (presently just 4.9 percent) before tapering off the subsidies to the customer," he noted.
However, Gill said the heavy industries ministry had already given a hint of this a few months back announcing that they are about to achieve their target of 1 million sales in 4 years and subsidy may not continue thereafter.
The ministry was left with no choice but to either suddenly stop the subsidy or somehow manage the rest of the year by greatly reducing the budget and drawing some unspent money from the E3W budget, he added.
"In the larger context, this may lead to higher bills of crude oil imports and add to the ever-increasing air pollution in most of the Indian cities," Gill said.
On the other hand, VoltUp Co-Founder & CEO Siddharth Kabra stressed the need for taking a holistic view of how the EV sector can grow to post the reduction in FAME subsidy.
"With the reduction of subsidy to 15 percent, it is clear that the electric vehicle ecosystem in India is growing rapidly and there is demand. While the immediate impact of subsidy reduction will be a rise in price and lower sales, the government in a way is allowing the industry to become independent," he said.
Kabra also called for the industry and the government to work towards creating a cohesive infrastructure development policy that provides impetus to the sector and helps in creating products that are efficient and cost-effective without compromising on quality and safety.
HOP Electric Mobility Co-Founder & Chief Operating Officer Nikhil Bhatia supported the government's move saying It was time for the EV industry to stand on its own.
"There was a need to have a more pragmatic approach to the long-term advancement and sustenance of the electric vehicle segment. Phasing out the subsidies is a forward-looking move, and it's time now that the dependence on subsidies is done-away-with gradually," he said.
Subsidies are no longer needed for the electric two-wheeler industry to thrive, and reducing and eventually removing FAME II subsidy is a welcome step in the right direction, Bhatia asserted.
Samsung Galaxy A34 5G was recently launched by the company in India alongside the more expensive Galaxy A54 5G smartphone. How does this phone fare against the Nothing Phone 1 and the iQoo Neo 7? We discuss this and more on Orbital, the Gadgets 360 podcast. Orbital is available on Spotify, Gaana, JioSaavn, Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music and wherever you get your podcasts. Affiliate links may be automatically generated - see our ethics statement for details.