Apple Tells Court Qualcomm Chip Licences Are Invalid

Advertisement
By Reuters | Updated: 20 June 2017 17:52 IST
Highlights
  • New attack could undermine a core tenet of Qualcomm's business model
  • Qualcomm takes a percentage of the overall selling price for iPhone
  • Apple said Qualcomm should charge for either a patent licence or a chip

Apple on Tuesday broadened a legal attack on Qualcomm, arguing to a US federal court that licence agreements that secure the chipmaker a cut of every iPhone manufactured were invalid.

If successful, Apple's attack would undermine a core tenet of Qualcomm's business model.

Advertisement

Apple sued San Diego-based Qualcomm in January, saying the chip maker improperly withheld $1 billion in rebates because Apple helped Korean regulators investigate Qualcomm.

Apple's initial lawsuit was a relatively narrow one focused on whether it violated a contract with Qualcomm by helping regulators that were investigating Qualcomm's business practices. But the new filing expands Apple's claims and seeks to stop Qualcomm's longstanding business model using a legal theory based on a ruling last month.

Advertisement

The US Supreme Court made it harder for manufacturers and drug companies to control how their products are used or resold, ruling in May against printer company Lexmark International in a patent dispute over another company's resale of its used ink cartridges.

In a Tuesday brief seen by Reuters, Apple took aim at Qualcomm's practice of requiring customers to sign patent licence agreements before purchasing chips, known in the industry as "no licence, no chips".

Advertisement

The licence allows Qualcomm to take a percentage of the overall selling price for iPhone in exchange for supplying the modem chips that let phones connect to cellular data networks.

Apple argued that the ruling involving Lexmark showed that Qualcomm was entitled to only "one reward" for its intellectual property and products.

Advertisement

Qualcomm should be allowed to charge for either a patent licence or a chip, but not both, Apple argued.

Apple wants to be able to buy chips without signing the licence agreement that forces it to pay a part of the overall iPhone sale price.

Apple also asked the court to stop lawsuits that Qualcomm had filed against Foxconn and three other contract makers that assemble the iPhone on Apple's behalf and are the formal buyers of Qualcomm's chip, as is standard in the electronics industry.

Apple argued that the court fight should be between Apple and Qualcomm.

© Thomson Reuters 2017

 

Get your daily dose of tech news, reviews, and insights, in under 80 characters on Gadgets 360 Turbo. Connect with fellow tech lovers on our Forum. Follow us on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News for instant updates. Catch all the action on our YouTube channel.

Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Philips TAB4304/94 Soundbar and Three Bluetooth Speakers Debut in India
  2. Google Announces Best Android Apps, Games of 2026 in India
  3. Motorola Edge 70 Neo All Set to Launch in India on This Date
  1. Vivo Y05s Google Play Console Listing Suggests It Could Be a Rebranded Vivo Y05 4G
  2. WhatsApp Message Sticker Reactions Feature Reportedly Rolling Out to Android Beta Users
  3. BSNL Voice-Only Prepaid Plans With Unlimited Calls Launched in India: Price, Offers, Benefits
  4. MEXC Pulls the Plug on Visa-Linked Crypto Card Service Within Three Months After Launch
  5. Solana Foundation Acquires Majority Stake in Crypto Data Platform CoinGecko
  6. Grand Theft Auto 6 Review Roundup: Rockstar's Open World Title Becomes Highest Rated Game of All Time
  7. Philips TAB4304/94 Soundbar and Three Bluetooth Speakers Launched in India: Price, Features
  8. Google Gemini Tasks Rolls Out to Free Users in India: Here's What You Need to Know
  9. Meta Tests Instagram Direct App With Messaging Features for Users Without Instagram Accounts
  10. Can AI Run a Factory? Siemens Launches Eigen Engineering Agent in India
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2026. All rights reserved.