Google Moving Away From Tracking Users via ‘Cookies’ Said to Be Drawing US Antitrust Scrutiny

Google's plan to block a popular Web tracking tool called "cookies" is a source of concern for US Justice Department investigators who have been asking advertising industry executives whether the move by the search giant will hobble its smaller rivals, people familiar with the situation said.

Alphabet's Google a year ago announced it would ban some cookies in its Chrome browser to increase user privacy. Over the last two months, Google released more details, leading online ads rivals to complain about losing the data-gathering tool.

The questions from Justice Department investigators have touched on how Chrome policies, including those related to cookies, affect the advertisement and news industries, four people said.

Investigators are asking whether Google is using Chrome, which has 60 percent global market share, to reduce competition by preventing rival advertisement companies from tracking users through cookies while leaving loopholes for it to gather data with cookies, analytics tools and other sources, the sources added.

The latest conversations, which have not been previously reported, are a sign that officials are tracking Google's projects in the global online ad market where it and No. 2 Facebook control about 54 percent of revenue.

The advertisement inquiry may not lead to legal action.

Executives from more than a dozen companies from an array of sectors have spoken with Justice Department investigators, one of the sources said.

The government has been investigating Google's search and advertising business since mid-2019, and last October it sued Google for allegedly using anticompetitive tactics to maintain the dominance of its search engine. It has continued to probe Google's advertisement practices.

Investigators also have asked rivals whether they encountered behavior similar to or worse than the advertising-focused accusations that attorneys general from Texas and other states leveled against Google in a lawsuit last December, the people said.

The Justice Department declined comment for this story. Google defended its ad business, saying it was helping companies grow and protecting users' privacy from exploitative practices.

"The enormous competition in ad tools has made online advertisements more affordable, reduced fees, and expanded options for publishers and advertisers," the company said.

If the Justice Department sues over ads-related conduct, it could file a new lawsuit or join the Texas case, one of the sources said. But antitrust litigation experts said the department also still had time to amend its existing complaint to include the ad tech concerns.

Texas on Tuesday amended its complaint to, among other things, allege that forthcoming changes to Chrome "are anti-competitive because they raise barriers to entry and exclude competition" in web advertising.

'Privacy concerns'

Google has been limiting data collection and usage across several of its services. The Chrome changes would affect advertisement tech companies that use cookies to collect people's viewing history to direct more relevant ads to them.

"We don't believe tracking individuals across the web will stand the test of time as privacy concerns continue to accelerate," Jerry Dischler, a Google vice president overseeing ad services, told an industry conference last week.

But smaller rivals dismiss the privacy rationale used by big companies such as Google and Apple to restrict tracking since they would continue to collect valuable data and potentially capture even more ad revenue.

"There is a weaponisation of privacy to justify business decisions that consolidate power to their business and disadvantage the broader marketplace," said Chad Engelgau, chief executive of Interpublic Group of Companies's ad data unit Acxiom.

France's competition authority on Wednesday temporarily allowed Apple to move forward with new tracking limits, saying privacy protections prevailed over competition concerns. The UK Competition and Markets Authority is expected to decide soon whether to block the forthcoming Chrome changes.

© Thomson Reuters 2021

Has the Redmi Note 10 Series raised the bar in the budget phone market in India? We discussed this on Orbital, our weekly technology podcast, which you can subscribe to via Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, or RSS, download the episode, or just hit the play button below.