Google list of paid bloggers not sufficient, judge says

Advertisement
By Reuters | Updated: 21 August 2012 09:35 IST
Google Inc failed to comply with a court order to disclose the bloggers and other commentators on a patent and copyright case who might have been influenced by payments from the Web company, a judge said on Monday.

U.S. District Judge William Alsup gave Google until noon on Friday, August 24, to provide an amended list of public commentators on the high-profile case between Google and Oracle Corp who have received payments as consultants, contractors, vendors or employees.

"Just as a treatise on the law may influence the courts, public commentary that purports to be independent may have an influence on the courts and/or their staff if only in subtle ways," wrote Alsup.

Advertisement

Earlier this month, Alsup issued a highly unusual order, riveting technology and legal circles, that Google and Oracle identify all writers who commented on the companies' intellectual property lawsuit and who received money from the technology giants.

The lists, submitted by the companies on Friday, contained no huge surprises. Oracle acknowledged it hired blogger Florian Mueller, who often comments on patent issues, as a consultant -- a relationship that was already known.

Advertisement

Google acknowledged contributions to various groups but said it has not paid any of them to comment on issues in the case.

But Alsup said on Monday he was interested not only in authors that the companies paid specifically to comment on the case but also those who commented and received money from the companies in other ways.

Advertisement

"Rather, the order was designed to bring to light authors whose statements about the issues in the case might have been influenced by the receipt of money from Google or Oracle," Alsup wrote.

He cited Oracle's disclosure of Mueller as an appropriate response: "Even though the payment was for consulting work, the payment might have influenced the blogger's reports on issues in the civil action."

Advertisement

Oracle sued Google in federal court in 2010, claiming Google's Android mobile platform violated Oracle's patents and copyright to the Java programming language. It sought roughly $1 billion on the copyright claims.

Earlier this year, after the jury decided in Google's favor, Alsup ruled Oracle could not claim copyright protection on most of the Java material that Oracle took to trial. Oracle has said it will appeal.

In his initial order, Alsup said he was "concerned" about relationships between commentators and the companies, but the judge has not revealed what specifically has prompted him to act.

The case attracted heavy coverage from the mainstream media and technology-focused blogs.

Alsup said in his order that the payments in which he is interested do not include advertising revenue received by the commentators, and he said gifts to universities can be ignored. He noted that Oracle must supplement its list if the order clarifies any issues for Oracle.

"Google suggests that it has paid so many commenters that it will be impossible to list them all," Alsup wrote. "Please simply do your best but the impossible is not required. Oracle managed to do it."

A Google spokesman said the company would comply with the order. Oracle declined to comment.

The case in U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, is Oracle America, Inc v. Google Inc, 10-3561.

Copyright Thomson Reuters 2012
 

Get your daily dose of tech news, reviews, and insights, in under 80 characters on Gadgets 360 Turbo. Connect with fellow tech lovers on our Forum. Follow us on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News for instant updates. Catch all the action on our YouTube channel.

Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. PS5 Gets System Software Update With 'Security Fixes' Ahead of GTA 6 Launch
  2. Xiaomi Smart Band 11 Launched With 1.72-Inch AMOLED Display
  3. Xiaomi 18 Pro Series With Privacy Display Arrives Globally at This Price
  1. Xiaomi 18 Pro Max, Xiaomi 18 Pro Launched Globally With Privacy Display, Dual 200-Megapixel Cameras: Price, Features
  2. OpenAI Brings Computer-Use AI Agents to Healthcare for Medical Records and Insurance Workflows
  3. Pump.fun Adds Prediction Markets as It Looks Beyond Memecoin Trading
  4. Sony Rolls Out New PS5 System Software Update With 'Security Fixes' Ahead of GTA 6 Launch
  5. Gemini Users Can Now Save Their Chat History Without Opting in to AI Model Training
  6. Ex-Robinhood Engineer Admits Guilt in $125,000 Hyperliquid Fraud Case
  7. Oppo Find X11 Pro Max Tipped to Get Flat Screen, Quad-Curved Glass
  8. EvoFox Play V Wireless Gamepad Launched in India With Magnetic Hall 3D Joysticks for Sony’s PS5, PC and Smartphones
  9. WhatsApp Rolling Out Cloud Storage for Chat Backups on Android: Report
  10. Samsung Reportedly Developing Almost Bezel-Free Display for Future Galaxy Flagships
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2026. All rights reserved.