In a First, IBM’s Computer Debater Faces Off Against Itself

After first pitting the technology against a human last year, IBM challenged it to present opposing arguments, in a display of its latest advances.

Advertisement
By Associated Press | Updated: 23 November 2019 10:56 IST
Highlights
  • IBM machine was tested at the Cambridge Union
  • The computer system switched sides during the conversation
  • It also had to identify which side crowd-sourced contribution was on
In a First, IBM’s Computer Debater Faces Off Against Itself

IBM's Project Debater was for the first time being pitted against itself

The chamber hushed as the debate got underway at the Cambridge Union and the teams launched into their carefully crafted opening statements. The topic - whether artificial intelligence would do more harm than good - was something each side had a big stake in because both were using the technology to deliver their arguments. Cambridge University, home to the world's oldest debating society, was the setting Thursday night for a demonstration of what the future might hold. IBM's Project Debater, a robot that has already debated humans, was for the first time being pitted against itself, at least in the first round.

Artificial intelligence “will not be able to make a decision that is the morally correct one, because morality is unique to humans,” the computer system said in a synthetic and vaguely feminine voice.

“It cannot make moral decisions easily and can lead to disasters. AI can cause a lot of harm,” it continued. Artificial intelligence can only make decisions it has been programmed for and “it is not possible to program for all scenarios, only humans can."

Then, the machine switched sides, delivering the opposing team's argument.

Advertisement

Artificial intelligence “will be a great advantage as it will free up more time from having to do mundane and repetitive tasks,” it said, its voice embodied by a blue waveform on a screen set into a two-meter-tall sleek black monolith-like pillar.

Audience members at the society, which has hosted notable figures including British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, the Dalai Lama, and Microsoft founder Bill Gates over its 200-year history, were spellbound by its first non-human guest.

Advertisement

After first pitting the technology against a human last year, IBM challenged it to present opposing arguments, in a display of its latest advances.

Unlike its earlier debate, which relied on analysing a huge trove of newspaper and magazine articles for its replies, researchers this time crowd-sourced contributions from 1,100 Cambridge students and fed the answers to the computer.

Advertisement

They wanted to find out, “Can you use the technology to generate a compelling narrative that will help the decision maker to take a better decision?" said lead scientist Noam Slonim.

The system had to identify which side the crowd-sourced contribution was on, rank the best arguments, filter out spelling mistakes and bad grammar, then present a persuasive five-minute statement — a process IBM said took about a minute.

Potential applications for the technology include helping a company or government carry out surveys or gather feedback from clients.

The night wasn't totally devoid of humanity.

Project Debater quipped, "Let's move to an issue close to my artificial heart: technology," drawing laughter from the crowd.

And then human debaters took over in the rebuttal and closing rounds, while also jokingly dubbing the computer "Debbie" and "Cybertronia the All-Knowing.”

At the end of the night, audience members sided with the argument that artificial intelligence does more good than harm.

Its future is assured, at least for now.

 

For the latest tech news and reviews, follow Gadgets 360 on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News. For the latest videos on gadgets and tech, subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you want to know everything about top influencers, follow our in-house Who'sThat360 on Instagram and YouTube.

Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Vivo Y400 Pro 5G: Everything We Know Ahead of India Launch on June 20
  2. Oppo Reno 14 5G, Reno 14 Pro 5G India Launch Timeline Leaked
  3. Nothing Headphone 1 Price, Colour Options Leaked Ahead of Launch
  4. iQOO Z10 Lite 5G With 6,000mAh Battery Launched in India: Price, Features
  5. Redmi Pad 2 With 11-Inch 2.5K Display, 9,000mAh Battery Launched in India
  6. Nothing Phone 3 to Offer Longer Software Support Than Its Predecessor
  7. Apple Back to School Offer Brings Discounts on iPad Air, Other Products
  8. Infinix Note 50s 5G+ Gets a New RAM and Storage Option in India: See Price
  9. Government Announces FASTag-Based Annual Pass for Highway Commutes
  10. GTA 6 Delay Weighs on Global Videogame Market Growth, Data Shows
  1. BSNL Announces Q-5G Service in India, Launches SIM-Less Quantum 5G FWA for Enterprises in Select Circles
  2. SpaceX Launches 26 Starlink Satellites from California to Expand Low Earth Orbit Internet Network
  3. NASA and DoD Simulate Critical Abort Scenarios to Secure Artemis II Moon Mission
  4. Brain’s Built-In Signal Threshold Helps Differentiate Imagination from Reality
  5. Feather-Legged Lace Weaver Spider Uses Toxic Silk Instead of Fangs to Kill Its Prey
  6. New Habitability Model Helps Identify Which Alien Planets Might Be Able to Host Life
  7. Warner Bros. Games Restructures to Focus on Harry Potter, Game of Thrones, Mortal Kombat and DC Franchises
  8. Google Pixel 10, Pixel 10 Pro Alleged Case Suggests Minor Design Changes From Predecessors
  9. Oppo Reno 14 5G, Reno 14 Pro 5G India Launch Timeline Leaked
  10. Nothing Phone 3 to Offer Longer Android and Security Update Support Than Its Predecessor
Gadgets 360 is available in
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2025. All rights reserved.